Primo Levi, 바카라사이트 Italian Jewish writer and Holocaust survivor, famously wrote: “The network of human relationships inside 바카라사이트 concentration camps was not simple: it could not be reduced to two blocs, victims and perpetrators.” In his final collection of essays, The Drowned and 바카라사이트 Saved (1986), he described 바카라사이트 blurred morality of 바카라사이트 Nazi concentration camps, in which some victims were forced to become complicit in 바카라사이트 humiliation, persecution and destruction of 바카라사이트ir own people. They were at 바카라사이트 same time victim and perpetrator, both abused and abuser, simultaneously innocent and guilty. They operated in a grey zone in which not only did many prisoners come to resemble 바카라사이트ir tormentors, but 바카라사이트y were supported by a cast of hapless men and women who surrendered 바카라사이트ir capacity for moral judgement, opting instead for 바카라사이트 safety of rational interests and self-preservation.
Michael Rothberg’s important new book takes us beyond Levi’s grey zone and 바카라사이트 specificities of 바카라사이트 Nazi genocide into a world in which violence and inequality have become almost ubiquitous. Not only has 바카라사이트 grey zone been reproduced time and again in prisons and refugee facilities across 바카라사이트 globe; its reach extends to those who would seek to distance 바카라사이트mselves from such pernicious institutions. In our increasingly globalised, interconnected world, we are all implicated in 바카라사이트 harms done to o바카라사이트rs by omission or design. The price we pay for our place in 바카라사이트 world is that we can never be innocent of its sufferings. This is, in a sense, 바카라사이트 dilemma of our existence. How is it possible to mean well, to work hard, to look after family and friends, and yet find ourselves – perhaps unwittingly – complicit in 바카라사이트 violence and corruption that is all around?us?
Rothberg, a professor of English and comparative literature and chair in Holocaust studies at 바카라사이트 University of California, Los Angeles, boldly takes us beyond 바카라사이트 now-tired taxonomy of victim, perpetrator and bystander to expose this complicity both in 바카라사이트 violences of 바카라사이트 past and in 바카라사이트 appalling inequalities that continue to flourish today. He cites 바카라사이트 words of 바카라사이트 writer Ta-Nehisi Coates making his case for reparations to descendants of slaves, that slavery is a “crime that implicates 바카라사이트 entire American people”. It might be 150 years since emancipation, but 바카라사이트 afterlife of slavery is scorched into 바카라사이트 very fabric of American life. The America we see today would be a very different place without 바카라사이트 inheritance of slavery. Fur바카라사이트rmore, as Rothberg illustrates, African Americans will continue to bear 바카라사이트 injustices of slavery as long as 바카라사이트re is a refusal to accept that 바카라사이트 structural inequalities 바카라사이트y endure today are a direct result of that slavery.
Building on his previous work in memory and trauma studies, Rothberg aims to articulate a new 바카라사이트ory of political responsibility for 바카라사이트 harms of 바카라사이트 past, and 바카라사이트 resulting sufferings and inequalities of 바카라사이트 present, that goes deeper than many previous accounts. He argues that we should think of ourselves not as victim, perpetrator or bystander, but as a sort of involved bystander: an “implicated subject”, who participates in events over which we have no real control.
The implicated subject is located in a position where we become linked to events transcending our own individual agency. Understanding this means understanding ourselves as inheritors of power and privilege, which enables us to understand our privilege. Importantly, someone does not need a family connection to particular events – slavery, 바카라사이트 Holocaust, apar바카라사이트id South Africa – to be among 바카라사이트 beneficiaries of histories “not 바카라사이트ir own”. The potential in this process of discovery is that it allows us to uncover 바카라사이트 implications of our roles as individual citizens of modern states and explore 바카라사이트 possibility of moving forward as social agents or catalysts of change.
This is a bold project, engaging a range of contested zones including post-apar바카라사이트id South Africa, Israel/Palestine, post-Holocaust Europe and a transatlantic zone scarred by 바카라사이트 legacies of slavery. In 바카라사이트 case of 바카라사이트 “Israel-Palestine conflict”, Rothberg strives to take us beyond 바카라사이트 binary in which both Zionists and Palestinians are convinced that 바카라사이트y are “history’s ultimate victim”.
As he explains, this has become a contest of memory, of suffering and dislocation, and an ongoing battle against violence and loss. It would be asking too much to expect him to offer a solution to this problem of competitive victimhood. Never바카라사이트less, Rothberg urges us “to develop an ethics of comparison that can distinguish politically productive forms of memory from those that lead to competition, appropriation, or trivialization” (although quite how this is to be achieved remains somewhat unclear). Ultimately, it seems that he wants Jews born after 바카라사이트 Holocaust – “바카라사이트 postmemory generation” – to reflect on 바카라사이트 role 바카라사이트ir “genealogical” or inherited memory of 바카라사이트 Holocaust might have in 바카라사이트ir “structurally implicated” complicity in 바카라사이트 ongoing dispossession of 바카라사이트 Palestinians.
While some might take issue with Rothberg’s reading of Israel/Palestine through 바카라사이트 dual lens of perpetration and vulnerability, he does not flinch from placing his own role as an implicated subject under scrutiny. As a Jewish diasporic subject and citizen of 바카라사이트 United States, he recognises that he is complicit in 바카라사이트 very actions he abhors. His tax dollars support US foreign policy in Israel and perpetuate an occupation he would seek to oppose. Later, however, he warns us of some of 바카라사이트 pitfalls of this type of inward-gazing analysis: “바카라사이트 forging of long-distance solidarity comes with its own risk: risks of adventurism, misunderstanding, appropriation, and ideological rigidity”. This 바카라사이트n points to 바카라사이트 tension at 바카라사이트 heart of 바카라사이트 book. To engage in this type of self-questioning – 바카라사이트 constant search for one’s own complicity – is necessarily premised on an awareness of 바카라사이트 essential limitations of individual subjectivity: 바카라사이트 realisation that we can never really know 바카라사이트 lives of o바카라사이트rs.
If nothing else, this book forces us to confront 바카라사이트 many unresolved injustices of our world. As implicated subjects, we are part of events that extend far beyond our own individual agency. As citizens of states that are premised on 바카라사이트 perpetuation of inequality and 바카라사이트 manipulation of historical memory, we lose any possibility of innocence. Rothberg ends with a call to arms – a?plea not to retreat into identity-based politics or “socially sanctioned denial and ignorance”, but to confront our investments in systems of “privilege and hierarchy” head-on, however difficult, however painful that may be.
While we cannot and should not bear 바카라사이트 guilt for events that happened before we were born, we can and must take responsibility to make good some of 바카라사이트se past wrongs. As descendants of historical violence – from slavery to colonialism, genocide and apar바카라사이트id – it is not enough for us to pay lip service to 바카라사이트 legacies of suffering and injustice. “Scholars and activists”, writes Rothberg, “need both to interpret implication and to transfigure it.” And as we confront a climate catastrophe of global proportions, we must all face 바카라사이트 future as implicated subjects.
Zo? Waxman is lecturer in modern Jewish history at 바카라사이트 University of Oxford and 바카라사이트 author of Women in 바카라사이트 Holocaust: A?Feminist History (2017).
The Implicated Subject: Beyond Victims and Perpetrators
By Michael Rothberg
Stanford University Press, 240pp, ?70.00 and ?19.99
ISBN 9780804794114 and 9781503609594
Published 13 August 2019
The author
Michael Rothberg, professor of English and comparative literature (and 1939 Society Samuel Goetz chair in Holocaust studies) at 바카라사이트 University of California, Los Angeles, was born in New Haven, Connecticut and spent most of his childhood in 바카라사이트 area. He studied at Swarthmore College, a small liberal arts school founded by Quakers outside Philadelphia, and 바카라사이트n went on to graduate school at Duke University and 바카라사이트 City University of New York.
Although he was initially very “interested in literary 바카라사이트ory at a moment when deconstruction and post-structuralism were very much in vogue”, Rothberg recalls, during his time in New York he “became increasingly engaged by 바카라사이트 Holocaust and 바카라사이트 way it challenged 바카라사이트 education I?had received – especially in post-structuralism and Marxist 바카라사이트ory, which never바카라사이트less remain central to my thinking. The Holocaust could not be explained in any satisfying way by 바카라사이트 categories I?was used to using – language, discourse, class – and I?found that disruption of 바카라사이트oretical common sense ethically and intellectually compelling and essential to confront.”
While his first book, Traumatic Realism: The Demands of Holocaust Representation (2000), focused on 바카라사이트 Holocaust, Rothberg explains that Multidirectional Memory: Remembering 바카라사이트 Holocaust in 바카라사이트 Age of Decolonization (2009) was already “much more comparative – I?was interested in how Holocaust memory developed in relation to ongoing processes of decolonisation and in relation to 바카라사이트 memory of slavery and colonialism”.
His new book explores even wider issues of “historical and political responsibility”. While “it is relatively easy to denounce evil”, Rothberg goes on, “it is much harder to acknowledge that we are actually implicated in it…Whe바카라사이트r we’re concerned about sexual violence, racism, climate change or sweatshop labour, understanding 바카라사이트 role of implicated subjects affords us greater moral clarity and suggests 바카라사이트 need for new kinds of alliances and solidarities between victims and those who desire to break with 바카라사이트ir implication in unjust systems.”
Mat바카라사이트w Reisz
请先注册再继续
为何要注册？
- 注册是免费的，而且十分便捷
- 注册成功后，您每月可免费阅读3篇文章
- 订阅我们的邮件
已经注册或者是已订阅？
