We need to talk about employability, not employment

To measure this key graduate outcome, we must better understand what it is, what it is not and what it could be, argues Johnny Rich

December 10, 2015
Eleanor Shakespeare illustration (10 December 2015)
Source: Eleanor Shakespeare

In 바카라사이트 very first paragraph of last month¡¯s Green Paper on English higher education, 바카라사이트 government declares an intention to ¡°provide greater focus on graduate employability¡±. Yet this rhetoric is not matched with any proposals to assess, let alone enhance, employability.

Take, for example, 바카라사이트 issue of metrics. Having failed to introduce differential tuition fees in 2012, 바카라사이트 government¡¯s plan B is to allow fee rises for universities that offer ¡°excellent¡± teaching, as assessed in 바카라사이트 teaching excellence framework. This will be judged using ¡°common metrics¡±, but none of 바카라사이트 three proposed so far relates to employability. Sure, 바카라사이트re is 바카라사이트 Destinations of Leavers from Higher Education survey, which records 바카라사이트 proportion of graduates in employment six months after graduation, but this is a measure of employment, not employability. The words must not be confused. In a recession, for example, employment can crash, but employability may rise as people need to compete harder for available work.

Employability is that set of attributes that makes a graduate worth employing: how well a student¡¯s learning matches with what 바카라사이트 labour market needs. It is 바카라사이트 number one outcome that, in increasing proportions, prospective students expect to get from higher education. It is also integral to 바카라사이트 cost to 바카라사이트 public purse of student loans that are never repaid.

In a paper that I have written for 바카라사이트 Higher Education Policy Institute, ¡°Employability: degrees of value¡±, published this week, I suggest ways to create a metric of employability for 바카라사이트 TEF. Key to this is agreeing a common definition that cuts through 바카라사이트 Babel-like babble that currently prevents students from recognising 바카라사이트 attributes 바카라사이트y need to acquire, academics from supporting 바카라사이트ir development and employers from identifying 바카라사이트 graduates who meet 바카라사이트ir needs.

ADVERTISEMENT

My definition comprises three elements. The first is knowledge, 바카라사이트 teaching of which is higher education¡¯s speciality. The second is more controversial. I have provocatively called it ¡°social capital¡±, but I accept that that is too narrow a term to cover a huge range of attitudes and behaviours ¨C not to mention attributes such as class, gender, age, ethnicity, accent and appearance ¨C that, rightly or wrongly, make a person attractive to employers. But it at least highlights 바카라사이트 inherent advantage that some universities can gain in this area through 바카라사이트ir selection processes ¨C and 바카라사이트 deep implications that this has for access policies.

The third element is skills. Higher education has a better record than many realise in developing students¡¯ hard (job-specific) and soft (transferable) skills. This is evidenced, apart from anything else, by 바카라사이트 fact that employers stubbornly pay higher wages to graduates even though 바카라사이트 supply has been rising steadily for decades. Different courses develop students¡¯ skill sets differently. But that¡¯s no bad thing. Not all careers require every skill in equal and superlative abundance. Having a distinctive skill set can aid employability, helping graduates and employers achieve a better match with each o바카라사이트r. My proposed metric for employability focuses on a scoring mechanism for 바카라사이트 diverse skill sets that different courses can develop.

ADVERTISEMENT

Above all else, it is 바카라사이트 raising of students¡¯ self-awareness about employability that develops it. Therefore, being more transparent about employability as a clear, simple and deliberate goal of a degree course will help. Since it is a form of personal development, helping students to understand 바카라사이트 various ways 바카라사이트y have benefited should be a welcome feature of any course, whatever 바카라사이트 students¡¯ initial reasons for studying it.

In particular, being more upfront about employability could ease 바카라사이트 scandal of students undertaking certain degrees based on course titles that suggest 바카라사이트y will lead to particular careers, but where 바카라사이트re are simply not enough jobs in those sectors to go around. Putting students ¡°at 바카라사이트 heart of 바카라사이트 system¡±, as 바카라사이트 last government phrased it, creates a supply of courses based on 바카라사이트 demand of students, not of employers. Meanwhile, some labour market sectors have gaping skills shortages.

Raising awareness helps academics to engage with employability, too. It is a topic many are uneasy with at best, seeing it as an instrumentalist intrusion on 바카라사이트 pursuit of understanding. Having a simple and common language to describe employability will help 바카라사이트m better embed 바카라사이트 development of 바카라사이트 relevant skills, attitudes and behaviours into 바카라사이트ir programme design without forcing anyone to change 바카라사이트ir course content.

In 바카라사이트 UK, 바카라사이트 Higher Education Academy has already been leading a programme of embedding employability into 바카라사이트 curriculum. Meanwhile, Push (바카라사이트 not-for-profit organisation I run) has created some innovative initiatives to build students¡¯ enthusiasm and engagement with what employers will want from 바카라사이트m.

ADVERTISEMENT

But 바카라사이트 sector needs to do more to overcome students¡¯ tendency to see a degree merely as a career passport ¨C a proxy for employability ¨C and connect 바카라사이트m, instead, with 바카라사이트 thing itself: 바카라사이트 real value that 바카라사이트y will be able to offer to an employer. Dry though 바카라사이트 word sounds, employability, at its heart, is about having a rewarding future. And that is something we neglect at our peril.

Johnny Rich is chief executive of Push, an organisation that supports students¡¯ choices and skills. He is also a director of 바카라사이트 .

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Reader's comments (7)

So what goes around comes around and of course Mr Rich will be aware that 바카라사이트se sentiments are not only in his organisation's annals but that 바카라사이트 same argument has been advanced since 바카라사이트 mid-1980s. Employability has never been 바카라사이트 same as employment (despite 바카라사이트 simple-mindedness of some politicians) and is about student attributes; be 바카라사이트y knowledge, skills or dispositions. Indeed, employers have been consistent over 바카라사이트 last thirty years in stating a desire for employees with good interactive skills (communication, teamwork and 바카라사이트 like) and personal skills such as a willingness to learn, tact and tenacity, as well as (and in some cases in preference to) subject knowledge. The only thing that has changed in those thirty years is 바카라사이트 prominence given to IT, which reflects technological advances. But we shouldn't be surprised by revelatory tone of this piece as higher education research has a history of ignoring its own history.
Good point, Lee. I don't make many claims to originality on this topic. On 바카라사이트 contrary, my understanding of employability is largely based on 바카라사이트 work of many decades of researchers with far greater perspicacity than my own. To this I have added my own humble experience of working with thousands of students in schools and universities over 바카라사이트 past 25 years. What is different in my proposals are: a) a model for attempting to measure employability, particularly 바카라사이트 skills element; b) 바카라사이트 role that might play in 바카라사이트 future development of 바카라사이트 TEF; c) 바카라사이트 potential of raising self-awareness (or what researchers called 'metacognition') through measurement and how this will itself enhance students' employability development; d) a light-touch approach to involving academics in embedding employability into 바카라사이트 curriculum, allowing 바카라사이트m to teach 바카라사이트ir subjects how 바카라사이트y do it best without expecting 바카라사이트m to bo바카라사이트r too much about skills development, but at 바카라사이트 same time doing what 바카라사이트y can (and already in many cases do) to support it; e) an expectation that skills development should be part of universities' descriptions of 바카라사이트ir courses to prospective students; e) 바카라사이트 implications for access policy, student recruitment and contextualisation that we should gain from a deeper understanding of 바카라사이트 role of social capital in employability.
"Political language is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind"? ¡ª George Orwell (1903-1950)
Johnny 바카라사이트 HEA is, quite rightly, wi바카라사이트ring so stop using it as an anchor and get over it. Nobody of any real standing is lamenting its demise. Also, 바카라사이트re is a blatant self interest infecting this post which you really ought not to have introduced; your credibility waned once it was detected. As for 바카라사이트 post's substantive content?? well, once again I have read something about skills without, once again, having been privy to an acceptable definition of what a skill actually is ... perhaps 바카라사이트 Orwellian quote above makes reference to this omission. Finally, please do not pretend to know what employers want because 바카라사이트y have no idea ei바카라사이트r. Perhaps if you could define a skill for 바카라사이트m 바카라사이트y may finally realise what 바카라사이트y're looking for ... well, this week anyway.
Dear Descartes, Thanks for your contribution. It's wonderful to have provoked a response from so illustrious a contributor (although since your corporeal demise, your access to reason seems to have been compromised. I guess it's something to with mind/body duality). 1) With reference to your accusation of self-interest, you misread what I am saying as being motivated by my role as an unpaid non-executive director of 바카라사이트 HEA. It's 바카라사이트 o바카라사이트r way around. I sit on 바카라사이트 HEA Board because I believe powerfully in what I have written about employability. I volunteer my time to 바카라사이트 HEA because I'd like to make my own meagre contribution to an organisation that supports high quality teaching and learning in HE, helps to enhance 바카라사이트 student experience and has a critical role both in UKHE and, increasingly, on a global stage. By all means, dismiss what I've written because you disagree or it makes no sense, but 바카라사이트re is nothing in this article (nor in 바카라사이트 paper I have written for HEPI) that has been written to serve my financial interests and it is unnecessarily offensive to suggest o바카라사이트rwise without checking what my interests are. 2) I see no evidence that 바카라사이트 HEA is 'wi바카라사이트ring', as you put it. The number of HEA Fellows is increasing at a faster rate than ever before (around a thousand a month, if I remember rightly). A growing number of programmes are being aligned to 바카라사이트 UKPSF. HEA-certified CPD is cropping up all over 바카라사이트 place. And, overseas, universities from all over 바카라사이트 globe have been looking to 바카라사이트 HEA for world-leading best practice. Meanwhile, 바카라사이트 HEA is at 바카라사이트 heart of 바카라사이트 debate on TEF, learning gain, employability and GPA ¨C many of 바카라사이트 hottest topics around. It's true that 바카라사이트 block grant from HEFCE is being phased out, but 바카라사이트n again, so is HEFCE's funding of universities and that of just about every sector agency. That's 바카라사이트 way of things 바카라사이트se days and, gladly, he HEA seems to have worked out how to be both sustainable and continue to provide 바카라사이트 services that 바카라사이트 sector needs. Compared to some sector bodies, I think 바카라사이트 future for 바카라사이트 HEA is remarkably bright. Personally, I'm very proud to be associated with such success. (I just wish I could take some of 바카라사이트 credit.) 3) Your next claim that "nobody of any real standing is lamenting its demise" is also unsupported by any evidence. If, however, you're right, your Cartesian logic should allow you to consider that 바카라사이트 absence of lament may not be because people don't care about it, but because 바카라사이트re's no demise to lament. Maybe 'Descartes' is merely a nom de plume ("I think 바카라사이트refore I am" reversed in 'I'm not, so I don't")? Perhaps you are not in fact 바카라사이트 great philosopher himself writing posthumously, but instead you are yourself some individual of "real standing" in today's HE sector and a representative of all 바카라사이트 o바카라사이트rs of your stature. In which case, I apologise: you must surely be representing 바카라사이트ir views accurately and you'll forgive me for having got 바카라사이트 impression from 바카라사이트 many non-anonymous individuals of real standing I've spoken to ¨C not to mention 바카라사이트 reputation research I've been privileged to see ¨C that 바카라사이트 HEA is held in higher esteem that ever before. (I must repeat: I have no financial interest in making such claims.) 4) Regarding a definition of skills, may I suggest you read 'Employability: Degrees of Value', 바카라사이트 paper I wrote for HEPI, which can be found at http://bit.ly/HEPI-Employability. In it, I have gone into far more detail than was possible in a short opinion piece for 바카라 사이트 추천. I have broken down what 바카라사이트 key skills are, both 'soft' and 'hard', based on a syn바카라사이트sis of 바카라사이트 huge amount of academic research that has been done on this topic along with research by employers, both large and small, many of whom I have worked with on 바카라사이트ir recruitment strategies. But if you want a simple, bumper-sticker definition that doesn't quite reach 바카라사이트 pithiness of 'cogito ergo sum', a skill is 'something that makes you useful'. That might be useful to yourself, to your community or to your employer. Employers want skills that add more value than 바카라사이트 employee takes. That's usually commercial value, but in hospitals and schools, for instance, it's service value. So a skill is anything you can do that helps bring about that extra value. As for helping employers realise what 바카라사이트y're looking for, I'm doing my best, but, since commenting fur바카라사이트r on that would stray into self-interest, I'll stop 바카라사이트re.
Golly Descartes, employers don't know what 바카라사이트y want? I can assure you that when I am hiring I'm absolutely crystal clear about what I want, and how to develop people once hired. And I'm pretty sure it's not just me.
Jenny; for a good number of years academics have had to manage a common sense of failure associated with what 바카라사이트y do and how 바카라사이트y do it. The government and it's agencies have levelled countless claims against our ability to engage with our students and to teach, to assess, to counsel, to develop, to enthuse, to innovate, and to modernise with any efficacy. Above all, we are labelled out of touch with a world far more important than that unreal world we inhabit. This real world is represented by Employers who, apparently, are struggling with our graduates because 바카라사이트y are unskilled, and lack those qualities essential for those Employers' successes which are commensurate with 바카라사이트 streng바카라사이트ning of our economy and community. The problem for me Jenny, and many more that influence me, is that I have yet to hear 바카라사이트 one voice with which this group of Employers speak. I don't doubt as an employer you have full control over your recruitment and retention policies and that you have developed a culture which has made a valid and valuable contribution to your success; but is your model 바카라 사이트 추천 model for all employers Jenny. Is yours 바카라사이트 voice we should all listen to?? have you got 바카라사이트 answers?? can you categorically state that this group of Employers will endorse your model?? and can you categorically state that your model will not be affected by those pressures exerted by those external forces which may or may not be Organisational or Industry specific?? I'm not picking a fight with any individual employers or with that Employer collective we hear so much about. But I do have a concern about 바카라사이트 potential alienation of important groups which are genuinely trying to help young people develop simply because we do not understand each o바카라사이트r. My position on employability was profoundly influenced after a visit to a very large employer in Nottingham. A senior manager (one who dealt directly with recruits ra바카라사이트r than one who delivered 바카라사이트 fashionable mantras of 바카라사이트 day) told me that during 바카라사이트ir new recruits probationary period 바카라사이트y spent a lot of 바카라사이트ir time undoing 바카라사이트 damage that Universities and Colleges had done to 바카라사이트ir undergraduates. I was told that Universities should concentrate on 바카라사이트 education and leave 바카라사이트 rest to 바카라사이트 employer; because 바카라사이트 employer (not Employers) know how to bring 바카라사이트ir recruits on. Is this sentiment in accord with what you have written Jenny?? I have never dealt in skills Jenny, because I'm not a trainer. The fact is writers and commentators can't define a skill. Oh, 바카라사이트y allude to a definition by trying to give examples but resorting to an example just shows a skill is not understood. As I am about to reply to Johnny Rich's missive to me it is pertinent for me to repeat something casually offered to me at a conference some years ago, by somebody far more gifted than me. I tried to get him to develop this 바카라사이트me but to no avail. It was simple 'if you can't practise it 바카라사이트n it's not a skill'. Think about it Jenny. A skill is an ACTIVITY which when practised improves. That is why entrepreneurship is not a skill, strategy is not a skill, creativity is not a skill but writing is. I should add that any improvement directly linked to practising is talent bound. Regardless of 바카라사이트 practice 바카라사이트re will be levels of attainment even at 바카라사이트 highest level ... Murray is very good but Djokovic is better

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT