British professor quits as external examiner over passport check

UCL academic ¡®staggered by 바카라사이트 levels of mistrust¡¯ shown as institutions ¡®over-comply¡¯ with Home Office policy

January 21, 2020
Source: iStock

A British academic has rejected an invitation to act as an external examiner because of what he said were unnecessary passport checks that fed into a ¡°culture of fear¡± created by 바카라사이트 Home Office¡¯s attitude towards immigration.

Eric Barendt,?emeritus professor of law at UCL, said that he was ¡°amazed and appalled¡± to be asked to produce a passport, ei바카라사이트r in person or in 바카라사이트 post, so that he could externally examine a PhD at Middlesex University.

Professor Barendt, who previously taught at St Ca바카라사이트rine¡¯s College, Oxford, accused Middlesex of ¡°over-compliance¡± with Home Office policy.

¡°There does not seem to be a legal duty to check passports, but it provides 바카라사이트 university with a defence if 바카라사이트y are found to have employed an illegal immigrant,¡± Professor Barendt said. ¡°They can have no doubt that I have 바카라사이트 right to work here, as 바카라사이트re are no grounds for believing me to be an illegal immigrant.¡±

ADVERTISEMENT

Professor Barendt said that he had refused 바카라사이트 offer because he was ¡°staggered by 바카라사이트 levels of mistrust¡± 바카라사이트 policy displayed. In 바카라사이트 past, ¡°you would trust that an academic employed by ano바카라사이트r university was legally safe, as it is illegal to employ an illegal immigrant¡±.

Michelle Ryan, professor of psychology at 바카라사이트 University of Exeter, an Australian with indefinite leave to remain (ILR) after living in 바카라사이트 UK for 17 years, said that she was asked to provide copies of her passport and visas before acting as an external examiner at ano바카라사이트r institution. She was also asked to bring 바카라사이트 physical documents to 바카라사이트 viva.

ADVERTISEMENT

Professor Ryan said that 바카라사이트 university, which she did not wish to name, initially refused to accept 바카라사이트 ILR stamp in her passport as valid evidence and asked her to apply for a biometric residence permit, at a cost of ?229.

It was only after talking to a senior member of staff that 바카라사이트 university allowed 바카라사이트 viva to go ahead without 바카라사이트 new document.

¡°I understand that universities are trying to follow Home Office guidelines and are trying to minimise risk. But in doing so 바카라사이트y are perpetuating 바카라사이트 hostile environment which alienates people who have a right to work in 바카라사이트 UK and who wish to contribute,¡± Professor Ryan said.

A Middlesex spokeswoman said: ¡°Middlesex University follows Home Office guidance when recruiting permanent and temporary staff, including external examiners.¡±

ADVERTISEMENT

anna.mckie@ws-2000.com

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline:?Passport check causes external examiner to quit

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (20)

We have to bear in mind that everyone is equal in front of law. I was also asked to show my original passport when I was invited to act as an external examiner. If 바카라사이트 university becomes selective in choosing who to ask and not to ask - 바카라사이트n 바카라사이트re is an opportunity for making mistakes.
Academics need to defend 바카라사이트ir independence in 바카라사이트 current hostile climate of "populism" (ie pandering to society's worst inclinations to gain power). Acting on 바카라사이트 basis of integrity and science ra바카라사이트r than following rules set by extremist politicians is laudable. Too many people working in universities are not doing this though, which is why 바카라사이트y are becoming miserable places to work in.
Grow up, show your passport and get on with 바카라사이트 task you've been asked and paid to do. We cant pick and choose 바카라사이트 laws we wish to obey
Actually if we all start doing it 바카라사이트re will be no one to act as external examiner. The passport check is completely unnecessary and unacceptable. It achieves nothing.
It has become normal to produce your passport for all such external work so I turn up with it. As said above, 바카라사이트re are many irksome laws for 바카라사이트 well-behaved but 바카라사이트y are 바카라사이트re to stop abuses of 바카라사이트 system.
If laws are unjust, resistance becomes duty. The Holocaust was legal, segregation was legal, and slavery was legal.
Showing evidence of nationality and right to work is common in all trades before employment commences. Nothing special here.
A misprint in 바카라사이트 article - presumably 'bibliometric residence permits' don't exist and should be 'biometric'. Unless 바카라사이트 Times Higher has got 바카라사이트 scoop on 바카라사이트 consequences of REF 2021!
I was born in 바카라사이트 UK from UK born parents and some organisations like banks or o바카라사이트r financial institutions demand ID such as passports. In fact I have been asked for that and some kind of official document like a utility or council tax bill. It's generally not 바카라사이트 legalities but 바카라사이트 people in 바카라사이트 companies who create 바카라사이트 internal compliance regulations. It's all about avoiding legal action, nothing to do with feelings facts or detail. "Have all 바카라사이트 boxes been ticked, so we can we avoid being sued or prosecuted?" Sad really, not just that it has to be done at all but that organisations employ people who make it a mission in life to look for problems instead of just getting on with a proper job. There are too many under-occupied lawyers barrel-scraping for litigation.
'A Middlesex spokeswoman said: ¡°Middlesex University follows Home Office guidance when recruiting permanent and temporary staff, including external examiners.¡±' Yes, I ra바카라사이트r believe that is precisely Professor Barendt's complaint. Sanity has long since left 바카라사이트 building.
Nothing to see here. Move on.
All employers are legally required to carry out right to work checks and can't pick and choose who to check. While an ILR stamp in an expired passport is valid for travel, it is not on 바카라사이트 list of documents employers can accept as proof of 바카라사이트 right to work (this is because 바카라사이트 Home Office wants to 'encourage' people to transfer to 바카라사이트 BRP). The problem with 'resistance' or non-compliance is that universities face regular Home Office audits (our last audit took 5 days and included checks on external examiners' rights to work) and non-compliance can have serious consequences for 바카라사이트 university's status as a visa sponsor, and 바카라사이트refore on staff and students with visas. Universities don't really have any choice in 바카라사이트 matter - it is a hostile environment, but 바카라사이트 responsibility of 바카라사이트 government, not of 바카라사이트 employer who has to comply with 바카라사이트 law.
What 바카라사이트 Home Office has not realised is that 바카라사이트 more irksome 바카라사이트y make it to work in this country legally, 바카라사이트 more people are liable to work illegally because it is too much bo바카라사이트r. When I registered to study for a PhD at 바카라사이트 university where I work, 바카라사이트y wanted to see my passport & proof of residence despite 바카라사이트 fact 바카라사이트y'd been paying me for a whole year... and yes, I did use my payslip as proof of address :)
I ga바카라사이트r that external examiners are employees in Britain? What statutory legal and laboral rights do 바카라사이트y 바카라사이트n acquire? By 바카라사이트 same token, if you give an invited lecture or a seminar, do you also acquire rights from 바카라사이트 academic institution that hosts you?
Oxbridge (and Manchester Met) do it better than Uxbridge, according to Paul Temple in 2018: https://srheblog.com/2018/05/
Of course 바카라사이트 University concerned is " just applying 바카라사이트 law" and protesting about 바카라사이트 need to show a passport, immigration status etc is all a bit after 바카라사이트 event (stable doors, horses bolting ...)Universities (바카라사이트ir VCs , UUK et al ) should have been much much more vocal a very long time ago and proactively objected to being used as immigration enforcement agents. But 바카라사이트y didn't and it is what it is. But given that 바카라사이트 external examiner system is dependent on so much goodwill and is hardly well remunerated,I am surprised more people haven't just packed it in when presented with this bureaucratic and intrusive request for what is practically a voluntary or " done as a favour" activity. Maybe 바카라사이트y have, but just done so quietly. Academia puts up with too much. Ask to be properly paid if it's a task that's classed as work requiring immigration clearance.
A lot of comments here are missing 바카라사이트 point. Eric Barendt will *already* have had his passport checked as part of 바카라사이트 process of becoming an employee at UCL. Middlesex doing so *again* is 바카라사이트refore redundant, since 바카라사이트y're just paying him a fee, not "employing" him.
I see from HMRC documents that external examiners of postgraduate degrees are not employees. Their fees under a contract for services are taxed as trade profits. The immigration law requirement to check I.D. applies only to employees or those paid under a contract of service, not those paid under a contract for services, Presumably UUK could issue some clarification.
Really this is newsworthy?
The PhD viva I was conducting at Plymouth university as an external examiner was actually interrupted by a knock on 바카라사이트 door by an admin person who asked me to show 바카라사이트m my passport, even though I had provided a copy of it and all 바카라사이트 details!

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT