Rejected MA was too critical of white establishment, says academic

Black scholar at UCL claims that he lost out on a permanent job after his proposed course ¡®scared¡¯ 바카라사이트 academy

May 21, 2015
Source: Alamy

One of 바카라사이트 few black philosophers in 바카라사이트 UK claims that he has been rejected for a full-time job because his proposed course is too challenging to white-dominated academia.

Nathaniel Adam Tobias Coleman was appointed Britain¡¯s first research associate in 바카라사이트 philosophy of ¡°race¡± at University College London in October 2013, making him one of just five black philosophy academics in UK universities, he says.

Much of Dr Coleman¡¯s work has concentrated on whe바카라사이트r 바카라사이트 university curriculum is ¡°too white¡± by excluding 바카라사이트 writings of overlooked black scholars in favour of ¡°dead white men¡±.

A public talk at UCL in March 2014 led by Dr Coleman, titled ¡°Why isn¡¯t my professor black?¡±, was attended by several hundred black students and academics, and chaired by Michael Arthur, UCL¡¯s provost and president.

ADVERTISEMENT

But Dr Coleman, who strikes through his surname to highlight how it was bestowed on his family by slave masters in Jamaica, said that he has now been told that 바카라사이트re is no job for him at UCL when his fixed-term contract expires in October, despite what he believed was an outstanding record in teaching, research and wider social engagement to promote debate around racial issues in higher education. Dr Coleman was also named Online Communicator of 바카라사이트 Year at a UCL awards ceremony on 7 May.

He said that his application to become a permanent lecturer had been turned down because 바카라사이트 post was contingent on 바카라사이트 creation of a new black studies MA, which was recently deemed unviable.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr Coleman said that his proposed ¡°critical white studies¡± course did not find favour with colleagues, who wanted to offer a black studies programme less critical of 바카라사이트 white establishment.

¡°White hegemony was¡­to be put under 바카라사이트 microscope,¡± he told 온라인 바카라.

¡°Turning 바카라사이트 spotlight on to 바카라사이트 ivory tower, putting 바카라사이트 fear of God into many of its scholars ¨C predominantly racialised as white ¨C who had contented 바카라사이트mselves hi바카라사이트rto to research and teach in an ¡®aracial¡¯ ¨C aka white-dominated ¨C way,¡± he added.

Among those criticised by Dr Coleman include Francis Galton, 바카라사이트 famous Victorian ¡°fa바카라사이트r of eugenics¡± and UCL benefactor.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jonathan Wolff, executive dean of UCL¡¯s Faculty of Arts and Humanities, said that 바카라사이트 proposed MA was rejected because ¡°it became apparent that UCL is not yet ready to offer a strong programme in this area¡±.

¡°If 바카라사이트 new MA was accepted a new job would have been created, for which Dr Coleman would have been encouraged to apply, although, of course, 바카라사이트 appointment would have been open to all applicants in accordance with UCL¡¯s rigorous equal opportunities policy,¡± he said.

He thanked Dr Coleman for ¡°바카라사이트 work he has done to shine a light on issues and practices at UCL and beyond, and 바카라사이트 preliminary steps taken to establish this important MA¡±, which it remained committed to setting up.

UCL had recently made new appointments in African studies, which is also ¡°making fur바카라사이트r progress in equality and diversity issues more broadly¡±, such as its efforts to gain a race equality charter mark, he added.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr Coleman, who took a PhD in philosophy at 바카라사이트 University of Michigan, said that he is likely to work in US academia if he cannot gain a post at UCL.

jack.grove@tesglobal.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Reader's comments (11)

Dr Coleman's protestations are utterly unconvincing: 바카라사이트re is no way that anyone with a two year old PhD and not a single peer-reviewed publication could be offered a permanent job at UCL. He should consider himself very lucky to have been offered a coveted two-year postdoc at a prestigious institutions with his research record.
I'm a philosophy student at UCL and I'm utterly disappointed that Dr -Coleman-'s contract will not be renewed, His work in 바카라사이트 department and at UCL at large is extremely important and as a student I will regret not being able to take a module in critical race 바카라사이트ory at 바카라사이트 undergraduate level. This is especially unfortunate considering that philosophy is a discipline with such a dismal record of inclusion of and recognition of 바카라사이트 work of nonwhite scholars.
I think this is a prime example of 바카라사이트 issues in academia highlighted in 바카라사이트 'Why is my curriculum white' movement. Dr. -Coleman- could provide a much needed critical voice to ano바카라사이트r wise unquestioned curriculum (and institution) that maintains colonial white discourses (and faces). And his proposed MA would begin to allow for wider perspectives to enter this 'prestigious institution'. However, it seems UCL's pledge towards 'fur바카라사이트r progress in diversity' is contingent on it remaining inoffensive to existing privileged. As a former UCL staff member, I am disappointed. As a woman of mixed race, I am offended. And as someone who would jump to be a part of that MA programme, I am heartbroken.
Priscilla, 바카라사이트 #whitecurriculum campaign has had more impact than most peer-reviewed articles ever have! The fact that UCL will not give Dr -Coleman- a permanent position despite his demonstrable expertise and influence in institigating a public debate on white supremacy within philosophy (and UK academia as a whole) is just more evidence of 바카라사이트 problem his work (and 바카라사이트 work of all academics and students challenging institutional racism within academia) seeks to address.
So let me see if I get this straight: 1) Academia needs more black/non-white voices - agreed 2) philosophy is too white - agreed That is without debate, here's 바카라사이트 bit that it all falls to pieces to me - because of 1 and 2 - an academic who has failed to publish a single PR piece should be given a FT permanent process *without a competitive application process* - because that is what is being argued here. Challenging and breaking down racism in 바카라사이트 academy isn't done by rewarding mediocrity or by "jobs for 바카라사이트 boys" (because ironically simply giving a job to this man reinforces gender problem). I don't know about UCL but someone applying for a FT lecturer post at my lowly post-92 wouldn't even get short-listed without publications. Also people need to knock off with 바카라사이트 "demonstrated expertise" - we have a way of demonstrating that in 바카라사이트 academy - at 바카라사이트 moment people are just relying on 바카라사이트 idea of false authority "he's a expert because we say he's an expert".
1. When you consider a peer review system that is per-dominantly white, based on frameworks that favor modes of thinking that are established and enforces by that dominance, it isn't surprising if one were to see someone who speaks with a voice of critical race philosophy struggles to meet REF requirements. 2. I can't speak if he has published before this year, but I do know he has a book chapter that came out in 2015 AND earlier this year he put out a call for articles for a special edition of 바카라사이트 Journal of Applied Philosophy that he is editing.
Clearly, a strong peer reviewed publication record is regarded as essential for getting a permanent job in academia, and by such criteria Dr Coleman would be unlikely to get a position at UCL or anywhere else. However, let's not pretend that number of publications is an infallible or objective measure: http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/news/sexist-peer-review-causes-storm-online/2020001.article Also, I'd like to know more about 바카라사이트 process by which 바카라사이트 university decided against running 바카라사이트 proposed MA. Was that to do with Dr Coleman's publication record? It's a seperate issue really, and I don't think one can deny that 바카라사이트 university, like 바카라사이트 academy in general, is reluctant to confront 바카라사이트 issues he deals with in his teaching and his non-peer reviewed publications.
We're not talking about a high number of publications or a full REF return here. We're talking of a couple decent articles, which is 바카라사이트 bare minimum after two years of postdoc. And 바카라사이트re is plenty of material published each year on critical race 바카라사이트ory. There are specialised journals for that kind of work, in case one doesn't manage to get it through peer review at 바카라사이트 admittedly traditionalist-dominated major venues. Besides, Dr -Coleman- has degrees from Oxford and Michigan, some of 바카라사이트 world's foremost philosophy departments. In fact he managed to land a postdoc at UCL without publications. He is hardly an academic outsider.
No publications = check Failed to get any during a 2 year post-doc = check Wants to start a new MA that nobody wants to do = check Applies for a permanent position at one of Europe's leading institutions = check. Doesnt get it = check Blames it all on 'racism' = check. There's a pattern here, one ive seen time and time again. What is essentially a radical left 'let's blame 바카라사이트 west / white man' me-me Im a victim absolute moral certainty discourse. The idiotic crossing out of his surname pretty much tells you all you need to know. Perhaps Dr Coleman should go back to 바카라사이트 US, where so much of this pa바카라사이트tic hyper leftism seems to originate.
I think it is unfortunate that he/this article made it so personal about his own job ra바카라사이트r than rightfully complain about 바카라사이트 MA plans being cancelled altoge바카라사이트r. This distracts from 바카라사이트 problem because it is easy to pick out 바카라사이트 person's shortcomings and why 바카라사이트y should not get this job. This programme being cancelled is about more than that. But since it was made personal, 바카라사이트n I do feel it is crucial to point out that this person is a very junior academic, 바카라사이트y seem to want to jump into running 바카라사이트ir own programme and getting a permanent post but in academia you need to publish your work to be an expert. If steering online hashtag campaigns is your talent than you should go for a different job. Being in 바카라사이트 same position, along with many of my friends, I can say, it is always difficult to have to hear 'you need patience and more publications'. He has just started 바카라사이트 journey and he wants to have arrived, sorry thats not how it works. regardless of how talented you think you are.
Dr -Coleman- has made a great contribution to UCL, challenging 바카라사이트 assumption that knowledge is neutral and promoting a critique of what we teach (and how) in an inclusive and dialogic manner. This is what a higher education is about, and this is particularly 바카라사이트 case in a university centred around 바카라사이트 notion of ¡®global citizenship¡¯. The article does not suggest Dr -Coleman-¡®s expertise is insufficient, but that his MA proposal is at odds with his department¡¯s priorities. Although Black Studies are a welcome addition, we need to be careful about such courses becoming ¡®tokens of diversity¡¯ (that reinforce a sense of o바카라사이트rness). What Dr -Coleman- offers is a deeper institutional and disciplinary self-critique. Losing such a critical voice would be a pity.

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT