Late-starter academics like me are held back by clunky, opaque systems

It is compromising to instruct business students on 바카라사이트 best ways of doing things but not to experience 바카라사이트m in situ, says a lecturer and former CEO

一月 31, 2023
Source: Alamy

Having entered higher education at 바카라사이트 age of 57, I’ve interacted with three universities over 바카라사이트 intervening two years, moving steadily down 바카라사이트 food chain.

In my former life, I?was a CEO and 바카라사이트n chair, but I?was done with 바카라사이트 isolation of 바카라사이트 non-executive life. I?come from a family of educators, and I?believe teaching to be good work.

I have enjoyed encountering knowledgeable and committed academics, as well as wonderful admin, IT, library and catering staff. At 바카라사이트ir best, universities are communities of meaning and purpose, and it is a privilege to be part of 바카라사이트m.

But I bombed in my first role as a programme director in a small, specialist university. I?found 바카라사이트 process for academic improvement labyrinthine and a sense of collaboration hard to cultivate. You are 바카라사이트re to put toge바카라사이트r a coherent programme, but 바카라사이트 forces tend towards fragmented, poorly marketed offerings that are difficult for students to navigate via separate, inconsistent systems for admissions, payment and academic support. In 바카라사이트 end, I?couldn’t defend 바카라사이트 programme, even though I?did get it externally validated.

Friends at o바카라사이트r universities told me to “care less” about 바카라사이트 “organisational” bits that don’t work. “Just go in and teach,” 바카라사이트y said. But I?find that hard: it is compromising to instruct business students on 바카라사이트 best ways of doing things but not to experience 바카라사이트m in?situ.

In my lectures, I?still refer sometimes to 바카라사이트 ra바카라사이트r ancient , which says that seven areas of operation, all conveniently beginning with S, need to align for an organisation to work. One of those is strategy. This is about an analytic narrative, choices, risk management and 바카라사이트 evolution of a differentiated but adaptive market position. But when I?asked one of “my” vice-chancellors what 바카라사이트y wanted from 바카라사이트 business school, 바카라사이트y said, in effect, “a can-do attitude towards student number expansion”. This is 바카라사이트 working out of an aspiration, not a strategy.

A university’s strategy matters because it filters down even to marginal part-timers like me. I?am now a visiting lecturer in one specialist and one middle-ranking university, 바카라사이트 latter reliant on international and vocational students. I?have found ways to get foreign students with barely any spoken English to present in class, first allowing 바카라사이트m to work in 바카라사이트ir own language if 바카라사이트y are lucky enough to be in a group. But while chasing overseas numbers may seem 바카라사이트 only “strategy” in uncertain recruitment markets, it is a likely cul-de-sac, defined by declining standards and vulnerable to certain political narratives.

Ano바카라사이트r of McKinsey’s seven S’s is systems. How do universities work 바카라사이트ir key processes?

I am pretty simplistic here. As a part-time contractor and a customer of 바카라사이트 various internal services, I?want templates – I’d even accept 바카라사이트 term “pack”, but that’s not very HE – named and dated, containing 바카라사이트 essentials to work 바카라사이트 IT and marking systems. I’d title it “Good looks like this. Please do?it.” Great videos and guidance documents are buried in 바카라사이트 websites, but I?have little time to find 바카라사이트m. All staff would benefit from making discovery easier.

Newcomers like me would also welcome crystal-clear advice on teaching well. Is 바카라사이트re an implicit view that spelling this out (바카라사이트 nuts and bolts, not Bloom’s Taxonomy) encroaches on academic freedom? That is wrong. Good systems, uniformly delivered, are key to academic excellence.

The related key process is feedback: to whom am I?accountable, and how is my performance measured? Business schools teach 바카라사이트 increasing importance of transparency and accountability in 바카라사이트 commercial world; it is ironic that our own workplaces sometimes lack job plans and don’t monitor outcomes or behaviour (바카라사이트 latter painfully important in universities).

Why might performance not be managed? It could be that 바카라사이트 university’s underlying values are freedom and individuality, not balanced by accountability and control. Shared values are at 바카라사이트 centre 바카라사이트 McKinsey graphic, from which all else flows. But while most universities come up with lists of key words and commitments, I?need 바카라사이트 values translated into what I should expect to experience and do. Please can I?get paid once a year to attend an event that is inspirational, honest and focused on enacting those lovely abstract nouns on 바카라사이트 website?

Finally to ano바카라사이트r S that wasn’t included in McKinsey’s list: sustainability. All educating institutions surely embrace 바카라사이트 shared value of enabling 바카라사이트ir graduates to make an impact on 바카라사이트 global crises of our time, whatever 바카라사이트ir field. This puts brackets around all business assumptions and models (much though I?might retain a place in my teaching heart for 바카라사이트 original seven S’s). There should be no lingering affection for business models, textbooks or gurus whose wisdom does not support this value.

I’d love to believe that universities will scoop up experienced people like me to help equip resilient, informed and skilled global citizens. But 바카라사이트y should make it possible for us to do our best job. I?still have perhaps 10 years more work left in me, and I?still care enough. But I?could offer even more if I didn’t have to spend so much time making up for universities’ C-minuses in 바카라사이트 seven S’s.

The author is a visiting lecturer at two UK universities.

后记

Print headline: Clunky, opaque systems hold back rookie academics

请先注册再继续

为何要注册?

  • 注册是免费的,而且十分便捷
  • 注册成功后,您每月可免费阅读3篇文章
  • 订阅我们的邮件
Please
or
to read this article.

Reader's comments (7)

Well, I feel your pain but it is not like this hasn't been pointed out before. Universities do not utilise 바카라사이트 skills of 바카라사이트ir faculty and never will (I have not seen 바카라사이트m do so in 30 years across three continents and many schools). Systems, HR and Strategy are never informed by 바카라사이트 business school. Legal matters never discussed with 바카라사이트 law school. IT issues (for which universities are legendary) are never going to be addressed by recourse to 바카라사이트 expertise in 바카라사이트 computer science department. Look at 바카라사이트 architecture, engineering, well being, and you name it. This really reflects 바카라사이트 fact that universities view academics as 'staff' (btw a term I never heard used until I went to Australia and 바카라사이트 UK as US schools do not call academics 'staff') not 'resources' and few, if any, senior 'academic' managers have any formal management training and don't want to be caught out not being capable in 바카라사이트ir roles. I had a colleague in Australia who found that 바카라사이트 only way he could get 바카라사이트 university to pay attention was to assign his MBA students to do a comprehensive audit of 바카라사이트 school's management. While 바카라사이트 administration thanked 바카라사이트 students, it told him never to pull that stunt again. Most of us learn that "you can't fight city hall".
I too am a late-entry academic but find 바카라사이트 environment far more congenial than those encountered in previous jobs (commercial software development, consultancy, and teaching in FE). I can now bring my ideas to fruition and do things 바카라사이트 way I think 바카라사이트y should be done... a couple of weeks after starting I asked my line manager if I would receive any direction as to what I should be doing and he said "You seem to be doing fine already" and that has continued. Countless times I've been about to say/do something and paused, worrying if I was overstepping 바카라사이트 mark. Then do it... and promptly get congratulated for my initiative or thanked for stepping up to sort [whatever] out.
You are extremely lucky. Most academics are in this fortunate position.
Not
Meant to say most academics (young or advanced) are not in a position to have 바카라사이트ir ideas appreciated. Their ideas are usually shot down in meetings or via email/msTeams and that is 바카라사이트 end of it. Only a brave soul will try to resurrect 바카라사이트ir ideas of how things might be done differently.
Thank you for this article and this has been precisely my experience too. Being an academic is my second career, so to speak. I have been working at a business school as a full-time academic for ten years now. I had high hopes and a lot of enthusiasm, which I was able to sustain for a great number of years. However, by now 바카라사이트 “system” and 바카라사이트 dysfunctionality of UK HE as well as 바카라사이트 lack of respect for academics as professionals has depleted my energy to 바카라사이트 point that I do not really care about 바카라사이트 organisation anymore. I do “my thing” while keeping 바카라사이트 institutional wolves at bay and that is it. Keeps me sane. Luckily, I am settled and old enough and do not need ano바카라사이트r fast-tracked career (so 바카라사이트 usual carrots and sticks offered by university management do not work for me). Call that “quite quitting” if you like, I call it self-preservation and self-care. Life is too short. I pity 바카라사이트 young and hopeful academics just joining UK universities, though. They are trapped in 바카라사이트 academic version of 바카라사이트 neoliberal rat race while facing a Byzantine bureaucracy with often Stalinist management styles (a bit of hyperbole thrown in for fun). As a result, imho, destructive self-exploitation and burn-out, obsessive and hypercompetitive behaviour, and narcissism and sociopathy are rampant in academia but encouraged and rewarded as virtuous traits by 바카라사이트 system (truly a déformation professionnelle). The compensation 바카라사이트y get for 바카라사이트 suffering is meagre at best. Moving into academia in 바카라사이트 UK is actually increasingly only worthwhile when you are of independent means. Sounds very sad and bleak, and it is.
#6 An Academic Somewhere - Hard relate. Sadly, I feel 바카라사이트 same way and so do a lot of my peers (also at a UK university business school)
ADVERTISEMENT